The “King of Beers’” Latest Beer Tasting Extravaganza

Written by

Whenever I foresee a big beer tasting approaching, I start to pre-plan my days in ahead to prepare myself for the event.  I limit my beer intake the week prior (granted I was coming off a Final Four trip to New Orleans which involved all sorts of booze-induced revelry) and make sure I know what I am getting myself into beer-wise to be mentally prepared.  Just like a race, I need to know my beers, follow a good course, and hope to be at the finish line still standing (or at least leaning a little).  Unfortunately, I only stuck to one of my principles and my beer intake was pretty low going into the tasting.

Luckily, this wasn’t just a barleywine or imperial stout tasting, because some sours, kriek, and lambics were involved (my least favorite style of beer) to switch things up from the usual heavy hitting lineup.  If it wasn’t for the pictures the next morning, I may have been able to remember only half of what we drink.

Here is what went down (along with two bowls of popcorn which lasted as long as raw meat in a tigers den) and was split up amongst the six of us…

  • Great Divide Barrel Aged Yeti 2012
  • Bear Republic Racer X Imperial IPA
  • Goose Island Bourbon County Coffee Stout
  • Boulevard Bourbon Barrel Quad
  • Firestone Walker Sucaba
  • Weyerbacher Tiny (Belgian Imperial Stout)
  • Epic Brewing Big Bad Baptist Imperial Stout
  • Avery Rumpkin
  • Yazoo Sue (See John’s video review of Sue here)
  • Yazoo Sue (infected version)
  • Oude Kriek
  • Odell Avant Peche Imperial Porter
  • Russian River Consecration
  • New Glarus Raspberry Tart
  • Ballast Point Victory at Sea Coffee Vanilla Imperial Porter
  • Alaskan Brewing Smoked Porter 2009
  • The Duck Rabbit Porter

Favorite 3

3. Ballast Point Victory at Sea Coffee Vanilla Imperial Porter

Unlike, Bourbon County, this beer still had a decent amount of coffee to it.  Very complex beer and almost different flavors on each sip with your choice of coffee, vanilla, chocolate, or roast.  A very solid with a longass name.  Also, the label had a skeleton on it, that’s cool, right?

2. New Glarus Raspberry Tart

Don’t scan below where you will read that I don’t enjoy fruit beers or any type of fruit in a can, but New Glarus makes a hell of a raspberry tart beer.  If the Kool-Aid man enjoyed a good buzz, he’d break through a ton of walls for this stuff. OHHHH YEAHHHHH!  A smooth drinking raspberry concoction that hides almost any form of alcohol in it with a tartness biting you on the tongue in the end. With New Glarus only distributing to Wisconsin, you’re going to either have to drive up there or have a sweet hook-up.  Can anyone say the Great Taste of the Midwest in August 2012?

1. Odell Avant Peche Imperial Porter

Fresh warm peaches covered in chocolate sauce.  Yea, that’s the beer pretty much and it is awesome.  You take a look at the dark porter and think no way is this fruity.  By far my favorite, and maybe the groups, favorite beer of the night.  The beer is 45% ale with peaches added, 19% ale aged in oak, 36% ale aged in oak with peaches.  Peach abuses the beer as much as the Presidents of the United States of America abused the damn song (Dune Buggy was my favorite off the album).

Least Favorite 3 (No beer is horrible unless, well, you know)

3. Oude Kriek

I don’t like sours, I don’t like fruity. Good enough reason for me not to enjoy the beer, which happened to be the first beer of the evening sadly.  I was up sh*t kriek without a paddle.

2. Russian River Consecration

Shoot me now if you want, but I think Russian River is over hyped…just my opinion.  I’ve never liked any of their “tion” series and the only beer, which I’ve moderately enjoyed, is Pliny the Elder.  Consecration disappoints as well.  Their beers are just ok, not my favorite style choice or cup of tea.  The rest of the tasting group agreed.

1. Avery Rumpkin

I should have listened to my Colorado friends when they talked about getting Rumpkined. This pumpkin beer aged in run barrels stood at a staggering 16% ABV, similar to their Angels of Death series, and packed a huge, sweet, burning punch.  I am pretty sure I saw one guy just straight shoot the beer.  This beer was only meant in small doses to say the last.  It was not enjoyable and probably wasn’t a good call for our 3rd beer of the night.

Most Disappointing

Bourbon County Coffee Stout

The beer is relatively young and the coffee was Un-Starbucks like and no where to be found.  None on the nose, none on the tongue, none on your breath an hour later either.  For a beer as hyped as it is, big letdown.  Still a good imperial stout, but the label doesn’t advertise as promise.

Great Divide Barrel Aged Yeti

The nose wreaked of infection (as has been noted with this beer), but the taste, not so much.  Stankonia.  If you could get past the minor funky scent, it wasn’t a bad beer.  Some beers infection can do wonders to a beer (see Goose Island’s Matilda a few years back), but for this hairy monster of a beer…it wasn’t the case.

Until again, or I recover…whichever comes first.

John King
John King can kill two stones with only one bird. He is just that awesome. An Illinois native, John has learned to embrace the Kentucky culture by rarely using his turn signal and drinking his bourbon neat. An avid runner, outdoorsman, and carpenter, John has been able to integrate craft beer into all of these hobbies without a single trip to the hospital. Although his writing is sub-par at best, louisvillebeer.com employs him for his boyish charm and general affection for the local brewers.
  • Beau

    couldn’t even give the participants a shout out? Weak John. Really weak.

    • http://www.hatchcreative.net John Wurth

      I wondered the same thing, Beau. ;)

  • Beau

    Oh, it was a hell of a tasting as well. Can’t wait for the next one.

  • Pingback: Beer Tasting Extravaganza | Kentucky Brew Review

  • tronto

    John probably doesn’t even remember who was there…

Episode 32: Live Once More from Boombozz Taphouse

The fellas are podcasting live once again from Boombozz Taphouse in the Highlands (even though Wurth called it Boombozz in […]

Highlands Beer Festival – Spring 2014

It’s time once more for our favorite biannual craft beer festival in the Highlands.

My shoes are filled with Volga mud: (3) Beer hunters lurking nearby.

A travelogue in three parts. March 31: (1) A tale of a fateful trip. April 7: (2) The future is […]

Great Flood First Impressions (hint, they’re good)

Great Flood Brewing Company - Opening Feb. 2014

It finally happened folks.  Great Flood Brewing is officially open and pouring some damn good brews.  I’ve been down there […]

Ye Olde Mash-Up

Science strikes again!  For no particular reason, let’s talk about mashing today.  As with many of the topics that show […]

Great Flood Grand Opening Details

I stopped in to Louisville’s newest craft brewery, Great Flood Brewing, this evening, the night before their invite-only soft open, […]